Our November 2026 case-law update looks back at a High Court decision that every developer and adjoining owner in London should know. A developer was taking down a dangerous wall on the boundary. The neighbour put up scaffolding and built a new wall tied into what was left of it. The neighbour admitted trespass and nuisance, yet the developer’s claim for delay losses of about £45,000 a week still ran into trouble on the evidence.
Trident House Development Limited v Mohammed Yousaf (2025) EWHC 344 (Ch) was heard in the Business and Property Courts in Leeds on 20 to 24 January 2025 by His Honour Judge Klein, sitting as a High Court judge. Judgment was given on 21 February 2025.
The facts
Trident bought Galem House, a 19th-century former textile warehouse in Bradford, for £580,000 in October 2022, intending to convert it into 77 apartments. One wall of the building abutted a car park owned by Mr Yousaf. Nobody in the case contended that the wall was a party wall.
The sequence of events was as follows:
- On 5 June 2023 the council served a dangerous building notice under section 78 of the Building Act 1984.
- Deconstruction of the wall began on 2 January 2024.
- On about 25 January 2024 Mr Yousaf erected scaffolding and built a new wall tied into the remaining part of the Galem House wall.
- An exclusion zone followed. On 8 February 2024 the court granted a mandatory injunction before the claim was issued.
- On 20 February 2024 Trident began a claim under the Access to Neighbouring Land Act 1992.
Mr Yousaf admitted trespass and nuisance. That left two live questions: the terms on which Trident could have access to his land, and how much, if anything, he should pay in damages.
The access order
The parties agreed the practical terms of an access order under the 1992 Act: an exclusion zone of 8 metres by 6 metres on the car park, two working platforms, a period of up to 35 days, and two banksmen. What they could not agree was whether Trident should pay consideration for the access under section 2(5) of the Act.
Valuation experts gave evidence on that question. As reported in the judgment, the judge preferred the lower of the figures put forward, £1,268.40.
Why the delay claim struggled
Trident’s pleaded loss was about £45,000 for each week of delay. The neighbour’s wrongdoing was admitted. The remaining issues were causation and quantum.
As reported in the judgment, the judge was not satisfied that the neighbour’s wrongful conduct had caused the delay claimed. He looked at the programmes of works and the contemporaneous documents, and they did not bear out the case that the new wall and scaffolding were what held the project up.
This is the point with the widest application. An admitted trespass does not prove a loss. A claimant must show, with records made at the time, that the interference actually stopped or slowed the work on the critical path.
The surveying and expert evidence
Three strands of professional evidence appear in the judgment:
- The party wall surveyor. Trident’s party wall surveyor on the project, a chartered building surveyor, gave evidence.
- The building experts. The experts on building matters agreed all the key issues between them, so they were not called to give oral evidence. That is the outcome CPR Part 35 is designed to encourage: experts meet, narrow the issues, and save the court time.
- The valuation experts. They addressed the consideration payable for access, and the court chose between their figures.
How this differs from the Party Wall etc. Act 1996
The dispute was fought under the common law of trespass and nuisance and the Access to Neighbouring Land Act 1992. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 was not the route, because the wall was not said to be a party wall.
Where the 1996 Act does apply, the framework is different:
- Notices. A building owner must serve notice before building at the line of junction (section 1), carrying out works to an existing party wall or structure (section 3), or excavating near a neighbour’s foundations within the distances set out in section 6.
- Access. Section 8 gives the building owner rights of entry onto adjoining land to carry out works in pursuance of the Act, usually on 14 days’ notice.
- Disputes. Under section 10, surveyors are appointed and settle the matter by an award, which can deal with how and when work is done and with making good damage.
The 1992 Act is a fallback. It allows a court to order access for basic preservation works where the neighbour will not agree and no other right exists. It requires a court application, with the cost and delay that involves.
Practical lessons for London owners and developers
- Do not build onto or tie into a neighbour’s wall without agreement. However strongly an owner feels about what is happening next door, self-help of this kind is likely to be a trespass and to attract an injunction.
- Identify the wall’s status early. Whether a boundary structure is a party wall, a party fence wall or wholly owned by one side determines which legal route applies. A party wall surveyor can advise from the title documents and an inspection.
- Serve notices in good time. In London’s terraces and tight development sites, most boundary works fall within the 1996 Act. Early notice avoids the need for emergency applications.
- Record condition. A schedule of condition of the neighbouring property before work starts protects both sides.
- Keep delay records. Dated programmes, site diaries, photographs and correspondence are what prove, or disprove, a claim that a neighbour’s conduct caused loss.
- Use experts properly. Independent experts who agree what can be agreed shorten the trial and focus the court on what matters.
When to appoint a party wall surveyor
Appoint a surveyor before finalising designs for an extension, basement, loft conversion affecting a shared wall, or any demolition at the boundary. Adjoining owners who receive a notice, or who see work start without one, should also take advice promptly. Party Wall Surveyor London acts for building owners and adjoining owners across the capital.
Frequently asked questions
Was Trident House v Yousaf a Party Wall Act case?
No. Nobody contended that the wall was a party wall. The claims were for trespass and nuisance and for an access order under the Access to Neighbouring Land Act 1992.
What did the neighbour do wrong?
He erected scaffolding and built a new wall tied into the remaining part of the developer’s wall while it was being taken down. He admitted trespass and nuisance.
Did the developer recover its delay losses?
As reported in the judgment, the judge was not satisfied that the neighbour’s conduct caused the delay claimed, having regard to the programmes of works and contemporaneous documents.
Can I get access to my neighbour’s land to repair my building?
Possibly. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 gives access rights for works within the Act. Otherwise, the Access to Neighbouring Land Act 1992 allows a court to order access for basic preservation works, sometimes on payment of consideration.
Why do contemporaneous records matter so much?
Because a court deciding what caused a delay will prefer documents created at the time over later recollection. Programmes and site records were central to the outcome here.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specific advice on your own circumstances.
