Looking for expert solutions?
Request a Quote

Tag: aerial photographs

  • Moxon v Jackson (2026) UKFTT 1522 (PC): A Right of Way Claim Lost on Aerial Photographs and a 2007 Gate, What London Owners With Shared Passages and Rear Access Should Learn (November 2026)

    One sentence, written years earlier for a different application, did more damage to a right of way claim than anything the other side said. In Moxon v Jackson (2026) UKFTT 1522 (PC), decided on 26 October 2026, the First-tier Tribunal rejected a prescriptive right of way claim over a track in West Yorkshire after comparing a century of maps and aerial photographs with the applicants’ own earlier account of when they first had access [1]. The setting is rural, but the method is exactly the one a tribunal would apply to a shared side passage, a rear service road or a garage access in London.

    Judge Laura D’Cruz heard the case on 16 and 17 July 2026, with a site visit. All the parties represented themselves [1].

    Key Takeaways

    • A right of way by long use needs 20 years of continuous use, as of right, by the claimant and their predecessors.
    • If the use has been interrupted, the 20 years must be found before the interruption.
    • The tribunal relied on Ordnance Survey maps, aerial photographs from 1929 and the late 1980s, and Google Earth images from 2002 to 2023.
    • Earlier statements made in other applications, to the police and in planning documents were compared with the present claim, and did not match it.
    • There was no expert evidence. The judge interpreted the plans and photographs herself.

    The dispute

    The applicants bought their land near Daisy Hill, Morley, Leeds in 2002. In 2023 they applied to HM Land Registry to register a right of way, with or without vehicles, along a track leading from the road to one of their fields. They said the route had been used since the 1960s by the previous owner [1].

    The track crosses land in several ownerships. One neighbour did not object. The respondents, who own another part, did. They said direct access from the track into the field was only created in 2007, and that use along the track itself began later still.

    There was a long history between the parties, going back at least ten years, including earlier applications to the Land Registry.

    What a prescriptive right of way claim requires

    A right of way can be acquired without any deed if the route has been used for at least 20 years:

    • openly, without force and without permission (lawyers call this use “as of right”);
    • continuously, in the sense of regular use of the kind claimed;
    • by or on behalf of the owner of the land that benefits.

    The burden of proof is on the person claiming the right.

    In this case the track had been blocked by a parked car for 13 months in 2018. The applicants therefore needed to show 20 years of continuous use before that date. In practice, they had to prove that the track gave access to their field from at least the late 1990s [1].

    The evidence trail

    The judge worked through the documents in date order.

    Date Source What it showed
    1908 Ordnance Survey map The track as a residential street, stopping beside the last house
    1929 Aerial photograph The same
    About 1960 Map and photograph No apparent access into the applicants’ field
    Late 1980s Aerial photograph The track appearing to serve the field to the west
    2002 and 2003 Google Earth The same impression
    2009 Google Earth Clear access to the field, but by a kinked route and not along the track
    2023 Google Earth A shed built in 2013 standing across the kinked route

    Against that picture, the tribunal set what the applicants had said before. In an earlier adverse possession application they had written:

    “In April 2007 we installed a gate” [1]

    They had said the gate enabled direct access from their stable yard. The judge drew the obvious inference: if a gate was needed to gain access in 2007, there was no access there before. A police statement made in 2019 referred to use of the track for the previous 12 years, which also points to 2007. Planning applications for the stables had not shown the track as the means of access [1].

    The judge accepted that vegetation and shadow can hide things in aerial photographs. But the photographs were consistent with the applicants’ own earlier words. She was not satisfied that the track gave access to the field before 2007. Twenty years of use before 2018 had not been shown, and the Chief Land Registrar was directed to cancel the application [1].

    Why this matters in London

    London is full of informal access arrangements: a path across a neighbour’s garden to reach a rear gate, a shared passage between terraced houses, a service road behind a parade of shops, a route across a yard to reach scaffolding or bins. Many have no deed behind them.

    These arrangements come under strain when one owner builds. An extension, a basement or a garden room can narrow or block a route that a neighbour has used for years. Access disputes often arise alongside party wall matters, although they are legally separate. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 gives a building owner rights of entry to carry out work under the Act [2]. It does not create, remove or decide a private right of way.

    The evidence in a London case will be much the same as in Moxon v Jackson: old Ordnance Survey sheets, aerial photographs, street-level imagery, planning files, and what each owner has said in the past.

    Lessons for owners claiming a right of way

    • Check what has already been said. Statements in Land Registry forms, planning applications, insurance claims and to the police will be found and compared.
    • Identify the 20 years precisely. Work out which period is relied on and whether anything interrupted it.
    • Find witnesses to early use. The previous owner here had died, and there was no evidence from him. Statements from former owners and long-standing neighbours should be taken while they can be.
    • Look at the photographs first. If the historic images do not show the route, expect the tribunal to notice.

    Lessons for owners resisting a claim

    • Object promptly when the Land Registry gives notice of an application.
    • Keep dated photographs of gates, fences and obstructions, and records of when they were put up.
    • Record permission in writing. Use by permission cannot ripen into a right. A short signed licence can prevent a claim arising.
    • Do not block a route without advice. Obstructing a right that does exist can lead to an injunction and damages.

    What a surveyor could add

    No expert gave evidence in this case, and the parties were litigants in person. The judge did the work of reading the maps and images.

    A chartered surveyor instructed as an independent expert can make that work easier and more reliable by:

    • producing a measured survey of the site as it is now;
    • overlaying historic maps and aerial photographs at a common scale, so that features can be compared like for like;
    • explaining what can and cannot be seen in an image of a given date and resolution;
    • dating physical features such as gateposts, surfacing and fences from their construction and condition.

    The expert’s duty is to the tribunal, not to the party paying the fee. That independence is what gives the evidence weight. Parties’ own interpretations of photographs, however sincere, are submissions and not expert opinion.

    Conclusion

    Moxon v Jackson turned on a simple comparison between the claim made in 2023 and the record left behind over the previous decades. The photographs and the applicants’ earlier statements pointed the same way, and the claim failed.

    Any London owner relying on an undocumented route, or worried that a neighbour may claim one, should collect the historic maps and images, check their own paperwork for inconsistent statements, and take advice from a surveyor and a solicitor before making or opposing an application. If building work is planned next to a shared access, the question should be settled before the work starts.

    References

    1. Moxon v Jackson (2026) UKFTT 1522 (PC), decision of 26 October 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
    2. Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 8 (rights of entry), legislation.gov.uk. legislation.gov.uk.