Looking for expert solutions?
Request a Quote

Tag: boundary surveyor

  • Jarvis v Arkan (2026) UKFTT 1517 (PC): Where the Boundary Runs Through a Party Wall, Section 38 of the Law of Property Act 1925 and What the Tribunal Wants From Party Wall and Boundary Surveyors (November 2026)

    Neither side had permission to call an expert. Surveyor reports sat in the bundle but could not be relied on as opinion. A late request to admit expert evidence on the morning of the hearing was refused. The Tribunal then decided a determined boundary between two semi-detached houses using the midpoint of the party wall, a 1957 plan with no scale and fences that had stood for decades. Jarvis v Arkan, decided on 21 October 2026, tells every party wall boundary surveyor in London exactly what the Property Chamber does and does not want from them [1].

    Key Takeaways

    • The boundary between 12 and 10 Ashway, Corringham followed the midpoint of the party wall, projected in a straight line, for the central section only.
    • The front and rear sections followed the existing fences, which the Tribunal found belonged to number 12, with a note to that effect to be entered on both titles.
    • An approximate measurement on an unscaled 1957 plan cannot fix a line to centimetres.
    • The Tribunal said it does not generally need expert opinion on how to construe a conveyance or where the boundary ultimately lies; a surveyor’s value is in scaled plans and accurate on-the-ground measurement.
    • Expert evidence must be sought in good time under the Tribunal’s directions. A request on the hearing day will be refused.

    The dispute at 10 and 12 Ashway

    Tracey Jarvis and Graham Harriss own 12 Ashway, Corringham, Essex. Resat Arkan and Hulya Jayne Arkan own the adjoining semi-detached house at number 10, which they bought in 2020. The applicants applied under section 60 of the Land Registration Act 2002 for the exact line of the boundary to be determined. The respondents argued for a different line and also relied on adverse possession [1].

    Judge Ewan Paton of the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber, Land Registration Division) made a site visit on 5 October 2026 and heard the case on 6 October 2026, with both sides represented by counsel. The decision was issued on 21 October 2026 under reference REF 2025/0396 [1].

    The two lines

    Party Argument
    Applicants (No 12) Under section 38 of the Law of Property Act 1925 the party wall is treated as severed vertically along its middle, so the boundary runs along the wall’s midpoint and continues in a straight line to the front and rear of the plots
    Respondents (No 10) A 32-foot frontage measurement taken from the 1958 conveyance and projected to the rear fixes a different line

    The boundary depended on the 1958 conveyance of number 10 and a plan dated May 1957. The plan had no scale, thick lines and approximate measurements [1].

    What the Tribunal decided

    The conveyance and the measurement argument

    The Tribunal found that the respondents’ reliance on the 32-foot measurement was an attempt to fit the conveyance to the current position on the ground. An approximate measurement on a plan of that kind could not fix a line to centimetres. The disputed 32-foot measurement was checked by counsel before the site visit and agreed, so no tape measure was needed at the inspection [1].

    The party wall midpoint

    For the central section of the boundary, labelled B to D, the Tribunal gave effect to the applicants’ claimed line, the midpoint of the party wall projected [1].

    The fences and adverse possession

    The front and rear fences had stood in roughly the same positions for decades. The Tribunal inferred that the respondents’ predecessors, the Crews, had been in factual possession of land on their side well before 2003, supported by paving and enclosure, and that the respondents succeeded to that possession when they bought in 2020. For the front and rear sections, A to B and D to E, the boundary follows the existing fences, which belong to number 12, and a condition to that effect is to be noted on both titles [1].

    Outcome

    The application succeeded in part. Costs applications are to be made by a date set in the order. The judge urged the parties to resolve their wider disputes, which were outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction [1].

    The legal boundary and the physical party wall coincided in the middle of the plot. At the front and rear, decades of fences and possession took over.

    What the Tribunal said about surveyors and expert evidence

    This is the part of the decision that every party wall boundary surveyor should read twice.

    • Neither party had obtained permission to rely on expert evidence.
    • Surveyor reports already in the bundle were not admitted as expert opinion.
    • The respondents’ request on the hearing day to rely on expert evidence was refused because it did not comply with the directions.
    • The Tribunal said it does not generally need expert opinion on the construction of a conveyance or on the ultimate boundary question.
    • A surveyor’s main value lies in scaled plans and accurate on-the-ground measurements.
    • The Tribunal disregarded a surveyor’s commentary on photographs [1].

    Party wall surveyor or boundary surveyor: two different jobs

    London’s terraced and semi-detached housing means that the party wall and the legal boundary are often assumed to be the same thing. Jarvis v Arkan shows why the two roles must be kept distinct.

    The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 role

    A surveyor appointed under the Act deals with notices, awards, access and damage arising from works to a party wall or excavation near a neighbour’s structure. The Act does not determine where the legal boundary lies, and an award cannot do so.

    The determined boundary role

    A boundary surveyor instructed for a section 60 application produces a scaled plan to the standard HM Land Registry requires, measured on the ground and tied to the registered title, and provides the factual material the Tribunal needs. The legal conclusion about where the boundary lies is for the Tribunal.

    Where section 38 fits

    Section 38 of the Law of Property Act 1925 treats a party wall as severed vertically down the middle, with each owner having rights of support and user over the other half. In a semi-detached pair, that gives a strong starting point for the central section of the boundary, as it did here. It says nothing about the garden boundaries in front and behind, where conveyance plans, fences and possession decide the matter.

    Expert evidence in the Property Chamber

    The Property Chamber’s directions govern when expert evidence may be relied on, and the Tribunal applies them strictly. In practice, a surveyor’s report prepared for a determined boundary dispute should follow the disciplines of CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35: state the instructions, identify the survey method and equipment, separate measured fact from opinion, and sign a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and applies to chartered surveyors in tribunal proceedings as well as in court.

    The clear message from Jarvis v Arkan is that the Tribunal wants measurement, not advocacy. Commentary on photographs and views on who is right will be disregarded; an accurate scaled plan will be used.

    What this means for London homeowners

    • The centre of your party wall is a good guide to the boundary through the house, but the garden boundaries may follow old fences and long possession instead.
    • If you apply for a determined boundary, instruct a surveyor to produce a compliant scaled plan early and ask your solicitor to seek permission for any expert evidence under the directions.
    • Do not expect a party wall award to settle a boundary argument. It cannot.

    What this means for surveyors and solicitors

    • Party wall surveyors should refer boundary questions to a measured-survey specialist rather than offering a view in an award or correspondence.
    • Boundary surveyors should focus their reports on scaled plans and ground measurements, and leave construction of the conveyance to the advocates.
    • Solicitors must apply for permission to rely on expert evidence within the Tribunal’s timetable. A late request will fail, as it did here.

    Conclusion

    Jarvis v Arkan is a modest case about two semi-detached houses in Essex, but its lessons travel straight to London’s party wall market. The Tribunal applied section 38 to the party wall, applied possession and old fences to the gardens, and told the surveyors what it wanted from them: accurate plans and measurements, obtained with permission and in time. Any party wall boundary surveyor who takes that on board will serve clients better and avoid the costs of evidence the Tribunal will not read. The decision is published on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].

    References

    1. Tracey Jarvis and Graham Harriss v Resat Arkan and Hulya Jayne Arkan (2026) UKFTT 1517 (PC), First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber, Land Registration), Judge Ewan Paton, 21 October 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.