A plan drawn for a party wall agreement in 1960 labelled part of a Catford alleyway “Right of way to adjoining property”. Sixty-six years later the owner next door relied on that label to claim a fire-escape route across the alley. It was not enough. In RTC Investments Limited v Grantley (Catford) Limited (2026) UKFTT 1186 (PC) the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) rejected the claim on every issue [1]. For anyone involved in a party wall agreement or right of way dispute in London, the decision shows what old party wall papers can and cannot prove, and how much evidence a prescriptive right really needs.
Key Takeaways
- The claim to a right of way failed completely. The tribunal will direct HM Land Registry to cancel the application.
- A label on a party wall plan is not a grant. The judge said the wording “does not amount in law to proof that a legal or equitable right of way exists”.
- Rebuilding can end an old right. When the claimant’s building was demolished and rebuilt in 1973-74 with doors in different places, any earlier right was impliedly released.
- A fire door is not evidence of use. Having an escape route on a drawing is different from people actually passing along it for 20 years.
- Old sworn statements can outweigh live witnesses. A 1954 statutory declaration by a chartered surveyor was accepted. Both live witnesses were treated “with a considerable degree of caution”.
The properties and the claim
The two buildings stand side by side on Rushey Green, the A21 through Catford, London SE6. RTC Investments owns Duke House at 84-86. Grantley (Catford) owns 80-82. An alleyway lies within Grantley’s registered title. The two properties have never been in common ownership.
RTC applied to HM Land Registry on 30 May 2023 to register a right of way on foot along the alley, as an emergency route from two fire doors at Duke House. Its main case covered the whole alley. Its fallback covered only the front section, up to a point about a quarter of the way along. Grantley objected, and the Registry referred the dispute to the tribunal. Judge Simon Brilliant heard evidence on 17 July 2026 and closing submissions on 3 August, and gave his decision on 10 August 2026.
The right was claimed by prescription, meaning long use. That required 20 years’ use without force, without secrecy and without permission.
What the 1960 party wall agreement showed
On 9 June 1960 the then owners of 80-82 and their developer tenant entered into what the decision calls a “Party Wall Act agreement” with the owners of the property on the other side, number 78. It was made for the complete redevelopment of 80-82. This was long before the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, at a time when party wall work in inner London was governed by the London Building Acts.
The plan attached to that agreement marked the front of the alley “Right of way to adjoining property”, leading to “Access to adjoining buildings”. RTC argued that this showed a right of way already existed.
The judge gave the plan little weight:
- the words did not prove that any legal or equitable right existed;
- the plan “simply shows there is an access”;
- it was unclear how far along the alley that access went; and
- there was “no evidence as to what was the purpose of the access”.
A party wall plan records what the surveyors saw and what the works were. It is not a deed granting rights over a neighbour’s land.
The surveyor’s declaration from 1954
The most persuasive historic evidence came from a statutory declaration sworn on 13 December 1954 by Mr Frank Briselden FRICS, whose family had held the claimant’s site since 1898. The judge said its contents were “internally consistent, fit in well with the other evidence, and have the ring of truth”.
That evidence did not help RTC. It showed that there was no side access between the alley and 84-86 beyond the quarter-way point, and that an earlier occupier had only a personal licence to cross, which ended on his death in 1945.
Why the claim failed at each stage
On the modern period, the judge found that the claimant’s director was treating the existence of an escape route as if it were proof of use. Hard evidence of people actually walking the route was “virtually non-existent”. Tidying and maintaining the alley was not “passing and repassing” from the fire doors. A 2019 fire risk assessment even recorded that occupants “would not use this emergency exit”, though the judge suspected it had mixed up the doors. No supporting witness was called.
No expert or surveyor gave evidence at the hearing. Costs will normally follow the event, and the tribunal invited written representations.
Party wall agreement and right of way dispute lessons for London owners
1. Party wall awards and agreements are about works, not rights of way. An award under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 settles how notified works are to be carried out. It cannot grant an easement. Notes and labels on award drawings should describe what is there without suggesting legal rights that have not been checked.
2. Drawings last longer than memories. The 1960 plan was still being argued over in 2026. Surveyors should label plans with care. “Passage” or “alley” is a description. “Right of way” is a legal conclusion.
3. A schedule of condition can be valuable evidence. Dated photographs and notes of gates, doors and fences, made when an award is prepared, may help settle a later dispute about access. Several findings in this case turned on when particular gates and fences were installed.
4. Rebuilding changes things. Moving doors and access points can amount to giving up an old right. Owners planning redevelopment along a shared alley should have rights of way reviewed before the design is fixed.
5. Fire strategy needs legal rights behind it. If an escape route crosses a neighbour’s land, there should be a deed. A route shown on a fire plan is not a right to use it.
6. Prescription needs proof of real use. That means logs of fire drills, statements from occupiers, and photographs across the full 20 years.
Where expert evidence would fit
In access and boundary disputes a surveyor may be asked to prepare measured plans, date physical features such as gates, or interpret historic drawings. That is expert evidence, and in the tribunal it must be independent. From 30 November 2026 the RICS standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses (5th edition) applies to members who take on that role [2]. A party wall surveyor who made an award on a site should think carefully before also acting as an expert in a later dispute about the same land.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a party wall award create a right of way?
No. An award deals with the works notified under the 1996 Act and matters arising from them. A right of way needs a deed, a statute or long use that meets the legal tests.
How long must a route be used to gain a right by prescription?
At least 20 years, openly, without force and without the landowner’s permission, and with enough regularity for the owner to be aware of it.
Does an emergency exit onto a neighbour’s alley give a right to use it?
Not by itself. This case shows that a door and a route on paper are not proof of use.
Is this decision binding on other cases?
It is a first-instance tribunal decision on its own facts. The legal principles it applies are well established.
Conclusion
RTC Investments v Grantley (Catford) is a reminder that historic party wall papers are evidence of what was built, not a source of rights over next-door land, and that a claim based on long use stands or falls on real proof of that use.
London owners who rely on a neighbour’s passage for access or escape should check their title, gather evidence now and, where needed, negotiate a formal deed. Surveyors preparing awards and plans should describe access features neutrally and keep dated records.
This article is general information on a recent decision and is not legal advice.
References
- RTC Investments Limited v Grantley (Catford) Limited (2026) UKFTT 1186 (PC). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses. rics.org.
