Looking for expert solutions?
Request a Quote

Tag: howarth v austin

  • Howarth v Austin (2026) EWHC 2877 (TCC): No Party Wall Notice, Stripped Plaster and Hairline Cracks, Why the Neighbour’s Claim Still Failed and What London Owners Should Learn (November 2026)

    On 19 November 2026 the Technology and Construction Court in Bristol handed down judgment in Howarth v Austin (2026) EWHC 2877 (TCC), a party wall dispute between the owners of two Victorian terraced houses in Cheltenham. The claimant said her neighbour’s 2024 renovation damaged her home, breached the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 and amounted to trespass and nuisance. After a five-day trial in October 2026 with four expert witnesses, His Honour Judge Russen KC, sitting as a High Court judge, held that the claim failed.

    The houses are in Gloucestershire, but the problems are ones London terraces produce every week: internal walls removed, a steel frame inserted, plaster stripped from the dividing wall, garden walls rebuilt, and no schedule of condition recorded before any of it started. This article sets out what the court decided, as far as the published judgment allows, and what it means for building owners and adjoining owners in London.

    What happened between the two houses

    The claimant bought No. 33 in 2021. The defendant bought No. 32 next door on 15 December 2023 in a dilapidated state and renovated it during 2024. According to the judgment, the works included:

    • removing internal walls and installing a steel “picture frame”, supported by calculations dated 13 February 2024. The judgment records that the frame was chosen partly because it minimised load transfer and was thought to avoid the need for a party wall agreement;
    • removing substantially all the plaster on the No. 32 side of the main dividing wall, by shovel and not with power tools;
    • altering a rear bathroom roof, lowering the pitch from about 26 to 21 degrees and raising the eaves by about 120mm;
    • taking down the front garden wall in February 2024 and rebuilding it in October and November 2024;
    • removing about ten loose bricks from the rear garden wall in July 2024 and adding coping stones.

    A party structure notice was served on 5 June 2024, but only for a proposed porch and the reinstatement of the front wall. The claimant dissented and appointed her own surveyor. The porch was later abandoned. Building Control issued a regularisation certificate for the unauthorised works on 29 January 2025, which the judge noted is evidence of compliance but not conclusive evidence.

    The claimant issued proceedings on 20 December 2024. She relied on hairline cracking at several points in No. 33 and sought declarations, injunctions and damages.

    The result: the claim failed on causation and ownership

    The judge’s summary at the start of the judgment is that the claim fails. Two reasons stand out.

    First, the structural engineering evidence did not support a conclusion that the works on or next to the dividing wall caused the damage to No. 33. Second, the claimant’s case that she owned or co-owned the disputed garden walls was rejected.

    The defendant had already admitted that the main dividing wall, and the rear dividing wall up to the point where it meets No. 33’s roof, are party walls under the 1996 Act. So the case did not turn on whether the Act applied to those walls. It turned on whether the claimant could prove that the neighbour’s works caused her loss.

    The expert evidence: four experts, little agreement

    Each side called its own party wall surveyor and its own structural engineer. There was no single joint expert.

    The structural engineers

    The engineers inspected both houses together on 18 August 2026. They agreed that cracking existed and that some further cracking had appeared since. They could not agree on its cause, or on whether it was linked to the works at No. 32.

    Their joint position recorded two limits that mattered a great deal: records of the works were limited, and there was no schedule of condition recording No. 33 before the works began.

    The claimant’s engineer said the terrace behaves as an interconnected structure and that the alterations had not been assessed as a coordinated exercise. She did not dispute the strength of the steel frame itself. The defendant’s engineer relied on a trial pit showing continuous foundations about 1.0m deep, found no evidence of substantial settlement, and calculated that foundation pressure had risen by about 7.4%, against a 10% benchmark he described as an industry norm. Both accepted that the cracks were under 3mm. The defendant’s engineer thought some of them looked old.

    The party wall surveyors

    The surveyors disagreed about the status of almost every wall. The claimant’s surveyor relied on the presumption in section 38 of the Law of Property Act 1925 to say the walls were co-owned. The judge described treating “party wall” in the 1925 Act and in the 1996 Act as if the two meant the same thing as flawed. Both surveyors accepted that the meaning of section 38 was a question of law and not a matter for expert opinion.

    That is a useful reminder of the proper boundary of expert evidence. A surveyor can describe construction, bonding, age and alignment. What the statute means is for the judge.

    Three points of wider importance

    1. Stripping plaster can be notifiable work

    The defendant argued that removing plaster with a shovel was not “cutting into” a party structure under section 2(2)(f) of the 1996 Act. The judge had some sympathy with the argument but considered that plaster is part of the party structure, and that a hand tool can cut into it as well as a power tool. He treated the real question as one of causation.

    For London owners planning a back-to-brick refurbishment, the practical advice is plain. Wholesale removal of plaster from a party wall should be discussed with a party wall surveyor before work starts. It should not be assumed to fall outside the Act.

    2. No notice does not mean the neighbour automatically wins

    The judge reviewed Power v Shah (notice under section 3 is mandatory, and an award made where no notice was served is void) and Roadrunner Properties v Dean (where no notice was served, the court takes a reasonably robust approach to causation). He also noted that the Court of Appeal in Johnstone v Fawcett’s Garage in 2025 declined to adopt a general reversal of the burden of proof.

    The adjoining owner in this case still lost. A robust approach to causation helps a claimant with thin evidence. It does not replace expert evidence that the works probably caused the damage.

    3. Worry about workmanship is not nuisance

    The judge was not persuaded that general anxiety about the quality of a neighbour’s building work supports a claim in nuisance. Damage has to materialise. A claim for breach of statutory duty under the Act was not pursued at trial, and the judge commented that counsel was wise to leave it.

    What London building owners and adjoining owners should take from it

    If you are doing the work

    • Serve the correct notices for everything notifiable, including work that seems minor. The notice in this case covered a porch that was never built and did not cover the internal works.
    • A steel frame designed to avoid loading the party wall does not remove the need to consider the Act for the other works.
    • Offer a schedule of condition of the neighbour’s property. It protects you against claims for cracks that were already there.

    If you are the adjoining owner

    • Ask for a schedule of condition before works start, or commission your own dated photographic record.
    • Raise concerns in writing, early, and about the works that actually worry you.
    • Before issuing proceedings, get a structural engineer’s honest view on causation. Hairline cracks under 3mm with an alternative explanation make a difficult claim.

    How Party Wall Surveyor London can help

    We act for building owners and adjoining owners across London on notices, schedules of condition, awards and disputes. If works have started next door without notice, or you are planning a refurbishment that touches a shared wall, speak to us before positions harden.

    Frequently asked questions

    What did the court decide in Howarth v Austin?

    The Technology and Construction Court held on 19 November 2026 that the claim failed. The structural engineering evidence did not show that the neighbour’s works caused the damage, and the claimant’s ownership case on the garden walls was rejected.

    Is removing plaster from a party wall covered by the Party Wall etc. Act 1996?

    The judge considered that plaster forms part of the party structure and that it can be cut into with a hand tool. Whether notice is needed depends on the works, so take advice from a party wall surveyor before stripping a shared wall.

    Does failing to serve a party wall notice make the building owner liable for all later damage?

    No. The courts take a robust approach to causation where no notice was served, but the adjoining owner must still prove on the evidence that the works caused the damage.

    Why does a schedule of condition matter so much?

    It records the state of the adjoining property before work starts. In this case both engineers noted that no pre-works schedule existed, which made it much harder to say which cracks were new.

    This article is a general summary of a published judgment for information only and is not legal advice. It is based on the judgment as published on Find Case Law. The final orders and any costs decision are not covered here.