A mixed-use building in Penge was partially demolished on the council’s orders after works next door triggered severe cracking. The owner then tried to sue the developer’s directors, the contractor and both party wall surveyors for about £1.5 million, and in June 2026 the Technology and Construction Court struck the whole claim out. For anyone in London thinking about how to sue a party wall surveyor in a negligence claim, Kirupakaran v Ibrahim (2026) EWHC 1429 (TCC) is a clear warning about where responsibility under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 actually sits [1].
This article is general information, not legal advice.
Key Takeaways
- The adjoining owner’s claim against six defendants, including both party wall surveyors, was struck out on 11 June 2026 because it did not identify any duty, breach or causation, and no expert evidence had been identified [1].
- Neither of the two party wall awards had been appealed within the 14-day window, so the court treated them as unchallenged [1].
- The surveyors had disclaimed design responsibility, did not control the works and had no power to suspend them; the duty to compensate for damage sat with the building owner under section 7 [1].
- Security of £30,000 under section 12 had already been provided for in the second award [1].
What happened at 164 and 166 Croydon Road, Penge
The claimant, Mr Kirupakaran, owns 166 Croydon Road, London SE20, a terraced building with a fast-food unit below flats. Next door at No. 164, The Mitre public house with flats above was owned by MYK Properties Holding Ltd, a development company since dissolved. MYK had permission for third, fourth and mansard floors, a four-storey rear extension with a basement, and conversion into 10 flats. It engaged an architect, a structural engineer (Arcelle Consulting) and Crown Builders Contractors UK Ltd as main contractor [1].
Because the works affected the party wall, each owner appointed a surveyor. MYK appointed Mr Cook as its building owner’s surveyor and Mr Kirupakaran appointed Mr Randall as his adjoining owner’s surveyor [1].
The two party wall awards, the schedule of condition and the £30,000 security
The timeline shows the Act doing what it is designed to do [1]:
- Early August 2024: works began. Within about two weeks Mr Kirupakaran saw severe cracking and movement in No. 166 and on 15 August asked for the works to stop.
- 19 August 2024: Mr Cook inspected, identified cracking to both buildings, and agreed repairs would be done at MYK’s cost after the excavation and support works.
- 3 to 11 September 2024: damage increased; the contractor stopped all work except securing the property; MYK installed monitoring targets; Mr Randall instructed structural engineer Mr Richard Tant to oversee stabilisation of No. 166.
- Around 11 September 2024: the First Party Wall Award adopted a schedule of condition dated 10 June 2024 and governed the excavation and mass concrete foundations.
- 14 November 2024: after a schedule of repairs, the Second Party Wall Award recorded the condition of No. 166 as at 10 October 2024, provided for underpinning and rebuilding the party wall, and by clause 9 provided security of £30,000 under section 12.
Both awards recorded that the surveyors did not accept design responsibility. MYK’s consulting engineer designed the works and Mr Tant advised the claimant. Neither award was appealed or challenged [1]. Our guide to party wall awards explains what an award normally contains.
From cracking to emergency demolition
On 21 February 2025 the structural engineer advised that movement had increased, that the works appeared to have triggered existing defects, and that No. 166 was not stable enough for underpinning without a risk of collapse of the flank walls. In June 2025 the London Borough of Bromley gave notice of emergency measures under the Building Act 1984, stating that Nos 164, 166 and 168 were unstable and an imminent danger requiring immediate demolition. No. 166 was partially demolished [1].
The claim: £1.5 million against six defendants
On 2 September 2025 Mr Kirupakaran, acting in person, issued proceedings for about £1.4 million, later pleaded as £1,503,818. He sued two directors and an employee of MYK personally, the contractor, and both party wall surveyors. On 28 November 2025 Adrian Williamson KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, described the pleaded case as ‘hopeless’ but gave the litigant in person a chance to re-plead under an ‘unless’ order dated 1 December 2025 [1].
The Amended Particulars of Claim of 15 December 2025 alleged that the building owner’s surveyor ‘failed to halt works despite evident risk’ and that the adjoining owner’s surveyor ‘failed to act impartially and protect the interests of the adjoining owner’. The claim relied on the Party Wall Act, the CDM Regulations 2015, professional negligence and the common law duty of care [1].
Why the court struck out the sue party wall surveyor negligence claim
Mrs Justice O’Farrell heard the defendants’ applications on 4 June 2026 and handed down judgment on 11 June 2026. She granted every application to strike out or for summary judgment and ordered the claimant to pay the defendants’ costs [1]. The reasons are a checklist for any such claim:
- No duty, breach or causation pleaded. The pleading did not identify the duty owed by each defendant, how it was breached, or how any breach caused the loss [1].
- The awards were never challenged. Neither award had been appealed and no particularised criticism of either award was made [1]. Under section 10(17) of the Act an award is conclusive unless appealed to the county court within 14 days [2].
- No design responsibility. The surveyors had expressly disclaimed design responsibility; the works were designed by MYK’s consulting engineer [1].
- No control over the works. The surveyors did not control the works and had no power to suspend them [1].
- Compensation sits with the building owner. Section 7 of the Act, as reflected in the First Award, placed the obligation to compensate the claimant for loss or damage on MYK [1].
- Security had been dealt with. The section 12 security of £30,000 had been provided for in the Second Award [1].
- No expert evidence. The claimant had not identified expert evidence to establish the scope of any duty or any breach [1].
What a party wall surveyor is, and is not, responsible for
A surveyor appointed under section 10 resolves the statutory dispute by making an award, as the Government’s explanatory booklet describes [3]; see also our Party Wall etc. Act 1996 overview. Kirupakaran confirms three limits [1]: surveyors do not design the works, which is why awards routinely disclaim design responsibility; they do not supervise or control the contractor and cannot order works to stop; and they do not become liable simply because damage occurs. The statutory route for loss or damage is section 7, against the building owner.
Section 7 compensation, section 12 security and the 14-day appeal
MYK was dissolved by the time of the judgment [1]. A section 7 right is only as good as the building owner’s ability to pay, so section 12 security deserves hard thought before the first excavation. See Party Wall Act notices: what they are and how to respond for when to raise it.
Expert evidence: why a structural damage claim cannot get off the ground without it
A negligence claim against a surveyor or engineer normally needs expert evidence on what a reasonably competent professional would have done and whether the failing caused the loss. The claimant had identified none [1].
Here, a structural engineer would be needed to explain the mechanism of cracking and collapse, and an experienced party wall surveyor to say whether the awards, schedule of condition and monitoring regime fell below the professional standard. Under CPR Part 35 that evidence must be independent, address the court and be served with permission. A claimant’s belief that surveyors should have ‘halted’ the works is not evidence of breach. For the surveyors, clear awards recording the limits of their role and the security clause were central to the defence [1].
Before you sue a party wall surveyor: negligence claim lessons for London adjoining owners
- Appoint early and insist on a thorough schedule of condition; the June and October 2024 schedules were the agreed baselines here [1].
- Ask for section 12 security that reflects the real risk; deep basements and multi-storey additions on terraces carry collapse risk.
- Check who the building owner is and, for a single-purpose company, ask about insurance.
- Appeal the award within 14 days if you disagree with it.
- Pursue section 7 against the building owner first if damage occurs.
- Instruct the right experts before issuing proceedings.
How Party Wall Surveyor London can help
Party Wall Surveyor London acts for adjoining and building owners across Greater London, preparing schedules of condition, negotiating awards with appropriate security clauses, arranging monitoring and providing expert witness reports. Owners south of the river can start with our party wall surveyor South London page.
FAQ
Can you sue a party wall surveyor in a negligence claim at all?
In principle yes, but the claim must identify a specific duty, breach and causal link to loss, usually supported by expert evidence. In Kirupakaran none of those elements was properly pleaded [1].
What is section 12 security and how much should it be?
Section 12 lets an adjoining owner require security for expenses before works begin. The surveyors set the amount in the award; here it was £30,000 [1]. It should reflect the scale and risk of the works.
How long do I have to appeal a party wall award?
Fourteen days, to the county court, under section 10(17) [2]. After that the award is conclusive [1].
Do party wall surveyors supervise the builder?
No. The court confirmed the surveyors did not control the works and had no power to suspend them [1].
Conclusion
Kirupakaran v Ibrahim is not a case about bad surveying but about a claim aimed at the wrong people in the wrong way. The Act places the duty to compensate on the building owner, gives adjoining owners the right to security, and gives them 14 days to challenge an award. Surveyors who document their awards carefully are well protected; claimants who ignore the statutory scheme will struggle [1]. If works are planned next door, appoint your surveyor early, press for realistic security, keep the monitoring record, and take expert advice before any dispute reaches court.
References
- Kirupakaran v Ibrahim and others (2026) EWHC 1429 (TCC), Technology and Construction Court, judgment of 11 June 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Party Wall etc. Act 1996. legislation.gov.uk.
- Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, The Party Wall etc. Act 1996: explanatory booklet. gov.uk.
