Looking for expert solutions?
Request a Quote

Tag: power v shah

  • No Notice, No Award: Power v Shah (2023) EWCA Civ 239 and the Expert Surveyor Evidence London Adjoining Owners Need When the Party Wall Act Does Not Apply (November 2026 Case-Law Update)

    Two surveyors made an award of about £4,000 for a neighbour’s damage. The Court of Appeal held it was void, because the owner doing the works had never served a notice [1]. Power v Shah is not a new decision, but it remains the binding authority in November 2026, and it still catches London neighbours out. Where there is a party wall, no notice and damage, the dispute moves to court, and expert evidence becomes the heart of the case.

    Key Takeaways

    • Only the building owner’s notice triggers the Act. Without one, the surveyor procedure in section 10 cannot start [1].
    • Adjoining owners cannot invoke the Act alone. They cannot appoint surveyors on the building owner’s behalf where no notice was served [1].
    • An award made without a notice is void. Fees under it may be unrecoverable [1].
    • The remedy is in court. That means claims in nuisance, trespass or negligence, and possibly an urgent injunction [1].
    • Court claims are won on evidence. Independent expert surveyor evidence usually decides cause and cost.

    What Happened in Power v Shah

    The building owner started works without serving any notice under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. The adjoining owner believed the works fell within the Act. Its surveyor considered that a dispute had arisen and appointed a second surveyor to act for the building owner [1].

    The two surveyors then made an award. It gave the adjoining owner about £4,000 in compensation and provided for about £2,300 in fees for each surveyor. The building owner never took part [1].

    The surveyors tried to recover their fees in the Magistrates’ Court. The building owner asked the County Court to declare the award void.

    Court Outcome
    Central London County Court (HHJ Parfitt) Award declared void [1]
    High Court (Eyre J) Surveyors’ appeal dismissed [1]
    Court of Appeal, (2023) EWCA Civ 239 Result upheld [1]

    Why the Court of Appeal Said the Award Was Void

    The reasoning was direct [1]:

    • Service of a notice by the building owner is the sole trigger for the Act.
    • The Act gives rights to building owners. It does not give adjoining owners a freestanding right to start the process.
    • The section 10 dispute procedure cannot operate without a prior notice.
    • An adjoining owner cannot choose the Act in place of common-law remedies.

    The court relied on the earlier case of Blake v Reeves and said that remarks in Crowley v Rushmoor BC suggesting otherwise were wrong [1].

    No notice means no Act, and no Act means no award.

    Power v Shah, No Notice and Expert Evidence: What Adjoining Owners Need

    When the Act does not apply, an adjoining owner has two realistic routes. One is to press the building owner to serve a notice, which brings the Act back into play. The other is to go to court [1].

    In court there are no appointed surveyors to settle matters by award. The judge decides on the evidence. For a damage claim, that normally means showing:

    1. The condition before the works. A schedule of condition with dated photographs is the best proof.
    2. What changed. Crack monitoring, inspection notes and further photographs.
    3. Cause. Whether the neighbour’s works, and not age or earlier movement, caused the damage.
    4. Remedy and cost. The scope of repair that is reasonably needed and what it should cost.

    An independent chartered building surveyor usually gives this evidence, sometimes with a structural engineer.

    Party wall surveyor or expert witness?

    The two roles are different. A party wall surveyor appointed under section 10 exercises a statutory function between two owners. An expert witness gives opinion evidence to a court. Under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35, the expert’s overriding duty is to the court, the court’s permission is needed for expert evidence, and in lower-value claims the court may direct a single joint expert.

    From 30 November 2026, the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, also applies. It confirms that the primary duty is to the tribunal, requires any use of artificial intelligence to be identified in the report, and bars outcome-dependent fees except in exceptional circumstances [2].

    Practical Steps for London Neighbours

    If works next door have started without notice:

    • Write to the building owner at once and ask for a notice to be served.
    • Record the condition of the property now, with dated photographs.
    • Take early advice on an injunction if the works are risky.
    • Do not rely on a surveyor “appointing” for the other side. After Power v Shah, that does not work [1].

    If you are the one building:

    • Serve the right notices before work starts.
    • A missing notice does not avoid liability. It moves the dispute into court, where costs are usually higher.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can an adjoining owner start the party wall process?
    No. Only the building owner’s notice triggers the Act [1].

    Is an award valid if the building owner ignored the process?
    Not where no notice was ever served. In Power v Shah the award was void [1].

    What can an adjoining owner do instead?
    Ask for a notice, or bring a court claim in nuisance, trespass or negligence, with an injunction where needed [1].

    Why does expert evidence matter so much?
    Because the court, not a pair of surveyors, decides what damage was caused and what repair is reasonable.

    Conclusion

    Power v Shah closes off a tempting shortcut. An adjoining owner cannot force the Party Wall Act onto a neighbour who has served no notice. The dispute becomes an ordinary court claim, and such claims turn on clear, independent evidence.

    The next step for adjoining owners is to record the condition of their property early and take advice before damage worsens. Building owners should serve notices in good time.

    This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.

    References

    1. Cornerstone Barristers, “Court of Appeal rules that Party Wall Act awards cannot be imposed on building owners by adjoining owners” (16 March 2023). cornerstonebarristers.com.
    2. RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org.
  • The Party Wall ‘Trap’ for London Renovations, November 2026: Late Notices, Deemed Disputes and Why RICS’s Draft 8th Edition Puts Surveyor Jurisdiction Under the Spotlight

    {“content”:[]}

    A loft bedroom or rear extension can stall for months because of a letter that was never sent. That was the warning in a Property Investor Today report on 29 October 2026, which described a party wall “trap” catching out London landlords part-way through renovation [1]. The mechanics are simple: a late notice, 14 days of silence from the neighbour, and a deemed dispute under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. For anyone facing a party wall notice deemed dispute London scenario this month, the timing rules and the question of surveyor jurisdiction matter more than ever, because RICS is reviewing its own practice guidance on exactly these points.

    Key Takeaways

    • Most London loft conversions, rear extensions and basement digs engage the Act, even when built wholly within the owner’s own land.
    • Notice periods run from one to two months, and a neighbour who does not consent in writing within 14 days triggers a deemed dispute.
    • Without a valid notice from the building owner there is no jurisdiction: Power and Kyson v Shah (Court of Appeal, 2023, EWCA Civ 239) confirms an adjoining owner cannot impose an award.
    • RICS consulted between April and June 2026 on a draft 8th edition of “Party Wall Legislation and Procedure” that stresses the personal, statutory and independent nature of the surveyor’s appointment.
    • An appointed party wall surveyor and a CPR Part 35 expert witness are different roles, and the RICS expert witness standard (5th edition) takes effect on 30 November 2026.

    Why London Landlords Are Walking Into a Party Wall Notice Deemed Dispute

    The Property Investor Today piece, by Cameron Ilsley, identified three recurring mistakes: notices served late, builders scoping the job before anyone checked which elements touch the shared wall, and owners treating an informal chat with a neighbour as if it were a served notice [1]. Each can push the start date back or expose the project to an injunction.

    The report also cited Squarepoint Surveyors on a point that surprises many owners: a rear extension built entirely within the owner’s own boundary can still engage the Act, usually because of excavation near the neighbour’s foundations [1].

    Which Renovation Works Trigger the Act

    The Act applies in England and Wales and covers three categories of work; a fuller breakdown is on the types of party wall works page.

    Section of the Act Typical London works Minimum notice
    Section 1: new wall at or astride the boundary New flank wall for a side or rear extension built up to the line of junction One month
    Section 2: works to an existing party structure Cutting in steel beams for a loft or knock-through, inserting a damp-proof course, removing chimney breasts, raising or underpinning the party wall Two months
    Section 6: adjacent excavation Digging within 3 metres and below the neighbour’s foundations, or within 6 metres where the 45-degree rule applies, common for basements and deeper rear extensions One month

    Two features drive the trap: the two-month period for section 2 works runs back from the planned start date, and section 6 is triggered by depth and proximity, not by whether the new structure touches the neighbour’s property. Drafting and service are covered in the guide to party wall notices.

    How a Party Wall Notice Deemed Dispute in London Arises

    Once a notice is served, the adjoining owner has 14 days to consent in writing. If no written consent arrives, section 5 deems a dispute to have arisen. That is not a sign the neighbour objects; it is the automatic consequence of silence.

    A deemed dispute moves the matter into the section 10 procedure. The owners appoint an agreed surveyor or one surveyor each, and the two surveyors select a third surveyor in case they disagree. The surveyors then make an award fixing how and when the works proceed, usually with a schedule of condition of the neighbouring property attached. Work on the notifiable elements waits for that award.

    Realistically, the party wall process should start at least three months before the builders arrive. The building owner usually pays the reasonable fees of both surveyors where the works benefit only the building owner; the principles are explained in costs of party wall: the process.

    What Happens When Work Starts Without Notice

    An owner who starts notifiable work without serving notice has stepped outside the Act. The neighbour’s remedy is not a retrospective award but an injunction or a common-law claim. The Court of Appeal confirmed this in Power and Kyson v Shah (2023, EWCA Civ 239) [2][3].

    There, the building owner had served no notice. The adjoining owner’s surveyor treated a dispute as having arisen, appointed a surveyor on the building owner’s behalf, and the two surveyors made an award of about £4,000 compensation plus surveyors’ fees. HHJ Parfitt at Central London County Court declared the award void, Eyre J dismissed the surveyors’ first appeal in the High Court in 2022, and the Court of Appeal dismissed the second [2][3].

    The reasoning matters for every party wall notice deemed dispute London matter: the Act is triggered only by the building owner’s notice. Without it the section 10 procedure has no foundation, even if the surveyors followed every step correctly [2]. Once jurisdiction is missing, the surveyors’ authority disappears with it.

    Why Jurisdiction Is the Theme of RICS’s Draft 8th Edition

    On 10 April 2026 RICS opened a consultation on a draft 8th edition of “Party Wall Legislation and Procedure”, intended to replace the 7th edition. The consultation closed on 5 June 2026, and RICS said it would publish the responses in November 2026 [4]. As of mid-November 2026 the final edition has not been published, so surveyors continue to work to the 7th edition.

    As reported by Today’s Conveyancer, the draft emphasises that a party wall surveyor’s appointment is personal and statutory, and independent of client instructions. It strengthens guidance on fee practices, use of the third surveyor, service of notices and public engagement, and it responds to concerns about awards being challenged where surveyors acted without proper jurisdiction, including where no genuine dispute existed [4].

    Read alongside Power v Shah, the direction is clear: an award is only as strong as the notice that preceded it. Owners choosing a building owner’s surveyor or an adjoining owner’s surveyor should expect that surveyor to check jurisdiction before anything else.

    Party Wall Surveyors and Expert Evidence

    Appointed party wall surveyors are not expert witnesses, even though both roles demand impartiality. The appointed surveyor acts under the Act and produces an award; an expert instructed under Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules owes an overriding duty to the court and gives opinion evidence.

    The roles meet in three situations:

    1. Section 10(17) appeals. An award may be appealed to the county court within 14 days of service. Evidence on construction method, damage causation or the reasonableness of fees comes from a surveyor instructed as a Part 35 expert, not from the surveyors who made the award.
    2. Injunction proceedings. Where works have begun without notice, the court will want evidence on whether the works are notifiable and what risk they pose to the neighbouring structure.
    3. Damages claims. A schedule of condition taken before the works, with dated photographs, is often decisive. How schedules and awards fit together is explained in the party wall contract template guide on party wall awards.

    The RICS professional standard “Surveyors acting as expert witnesses” (5th edition), published in July 2026, takes effect on 30 November 2026. It requires disclosure of any AI use in preparing evidence, fuller disclosure of regular instructions from the same party, and reports that set out all assumptions and alternative conclusions [5]. A surveyor who acted as the appointed surveyor on a project will usually be conflicted from acting as an independent expert in later litigation about the same works.

    A Practical Sequence for London Building Owners

    1. Review the scheme at design stage against sections 1, 2 and 6 before tenders go out.
    2. Serve notices with full lead time: two months for party structure works, one month for new boundary walls and excavation.
    3. Diary the 14-day response date. If no written consent arrives, surveyors must be appointed.
    4. Agree the award before mobilising, including a schedule of condition.
    5. Keep every document: notices, proofs of service, appointments and the award.

    Adjoining owners can consent, dissent and appoint a surveyor, or agree to a single agreed surveyor. They cannot, after Power v Shah, start the process themselves; if works begin without notice, the right step is a written request for notice followed, if necessary, by advice on an injunction.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does a rear extension inside my own garden need a party wall notice?

    Often yes. Excavation within 3 metres of the neighbour’s foundations and deeper than them, or within 6 metres on the 45-degree rule, engages section 6 wherever the new wall sits. Cutting into the party wall for beams engages section 2.

    Can my neighbour force an award on me if I never served notice?

    No. In Power and Kyson v Shah the Court of Appeal held that only the building owner’s notice triggers the Act. The adjoining owner’s remedy is an injunction or a common-law claim.

    Conclusion

    The party wall trap described in October 2026 is really a timing and jurisdiction problem. Late notices create deemed disputes at the worst moment, and works begun without notice fall outside the Act altogether. RICS’s draft 8th edition pushes surveyors to check jurisdiction and act independently, and the incoming expert witness standard raises the bar for anyone later giving evidence in court.

    The next steps are straightforward: review the scheme against sections 1, 2 and 6 before tendering, serve notices with the full statutory lead time, and appoint a surveyor who treats the appointment as the personal, statutory role it is. Adjoining owners should respond in writing within 14 days and seek advice promptly if works start without notice.

    References

    1. The Party Wall Trap Catching Out London Landlords Mid Renovation 2. propertyinvestortoday.co.uk.
    2. Court of Appeal Rules That Party Wall Act Awards Cannot Be Imposed on Building Owners by Adjoining Owners. cornerstonebarristers.com.
    3. Civ. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
    4. Rics Launches Consultation Updated Party Wall Practice Guidance. todaysconveyancer.co.uk.
    5. Rics 2026 Expert Witness Guidance Key Changes for Surveyors. rimkus.com.