Looking for expert solutions?
Request a Quote

Email Service of a Party Wall Notice in London: Knight v Goulandris (2018) EWCA Civ 237 After Berow v Maidstone BC (2026) EWHC 635 (Admin) (November 2026)

Written by

in

{“content”:[]}

An award that cut a compensation claim from £821,210.49 to £55,001.61 reached the adjoining owner as a PDF attached to an email at 23:19 on a September night in Belgravia. He appealed fifteen days later, and the argument about whether that email counted as service reached the Court of Appeal. Anyone serving or receiving a party wall notice London surveyors have prepared, or a party wall award, should know how that argument ended, and how a 2026 High Court judgment about an email said to have gone to spam sharpens the point.

Updated 19 November 2026. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 15 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 lists safe ways to serve a notice or award. Since 6 April 2016 it allows email where the recipient has agreed and given an address.
  • In Knight v Goulandris (2018) EWCA Civ 237 the Court of Appeal held that section 15 is permissive, so an emailed award that is actually received can be good service.
  • In Berow v Maidstone Borough Council (2026) EWHC 635 (Admin), a licensing case that reviewed Knight, the High Court treated an email as served on the day it arrived, even assuming it went to spam.
  • The fourteen days to appeal a party wall award may therefore start when an email lands, not when a hard copy arrives.

Key Facts at a Glance

Two judgments matter: a 2018 Court of Appeal ruling on a London party wall award and a 2026 High Court ruling on an emailed council notice.

Point Knight v Goulandris Berow v Maidstone BC
Citation (2018) EWCA Civ 237 (2026) EWHC 635 (Admin)
Court Court of Appeal (Patten, Hamblen and Henderson LJJ) High Court, Administrative Court (Sir Peter Lane)
Date 20 February 2018 Heard 26 February 2026, handed down 17 March 2026
Email in issue Award forwarded on 2 September 2015 Decision notice sent on 2 September 2024
Time limit 14 days, section 10(17) 21 days
Outcome Appeal allowed: section 15 is not an exhaustive code Appeal dismissed: notice served on 2 September 2024

What Does the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 Say About Serving a Party Wall Notice in London?

The Act gives a list of approved methods rather than a closed rulebook. Section 15 says a notice or other document “may be served” in person, by post to the person’s usual or last-known home or place of business, or, for a company, at its registered or principal office [1].

Email was added by the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (Electronic Communications) Order 2016, in force from 6 April 2016 [2]. Section 15(1A) allows electronic service only if three things are true:

  1. the recipient has stated a willingness to receive the document electronically;
  2. that statement has not been withdrawn; and
  3. the document went to the electronic address the recipient specified.

The scale explains why this matters. The Government’s impact assessment, quoted by the Court of Appeal, counted about 226,800 party wall notices a year, with only around 1% served in person [3].

What Did the Court of Appeal Decide in Knight v Goulandris?

The court decided that section 15 does not shut out other ways of serving a document, so an award sent by email and actually received can start the appeal clock. Knight v Goulandris arose from basement works at 19 Chester Square that extended a party wall and caused some damage next door [3].

The two appointed surveyors could not agree on compensation. The adjoining owner’s surveyor put it at £821,210.49, including £640,000 for alternative accommodation. The third surveyor awarded £55,001.61 on 2 September 2015 and emailed the award to both surveyors. The adjoining owner’s surveyor forwarded it to his client at 23:19 that night, and the client read it the next morning.

The appeal to the county court was issued on 17 September 2015. Under section 10(17), either party has fourteen days from the day the award is served on him [4]. The building owner said time had run out. HH Judge Bailey, at first instance, held that email was not good service. The Court of Appeal disagreed and allowed the building owner’s appeal.

Patten LJ’s reasoning can be put shortly:

  • “May” in section 15 is permissive. The listed methods protect the server, because using them counts as service.
  • Other methods remain open at common law, but then service depends on receipt.
  • The risk shifts. In the court’s words, the burden is on the server “to establish receipt of the document in a legible form” [3].

The court gave no view on whether the 2016 amendment narrows that freedom, so some caution is still needed.

What Did Berow v Maidstone Borough Council Add in 2026?

Berow confirms that email service outside a statutory list is firmly accepted, and it says something new about what “received” means. Berow v Maidstone Borough Council was not a party wall dispute. A driver’s licence was revoked, the reasons were emailed to him and his solicitor on 2 September 2024, and his appeal was lodged outside the 21-day limit. He said the email had gone into his spam folder [5].

Sir Peter Lane reviewed Knight alongside Supreme Court authority. Three findings stand out:

  • Email is an accepted method. The judge said service by email at common law is “now beyond doubt”.
  • The spam argument failed. The spam point fell outside the questions stated for the court. In the alternative, even assuming the email went to spam, service was effected on 2 September 2024.
  • Reasonableness cuts both ways. Earlier dealings had been by email, delivery receipts showed the message had reached the recipient’s system, and the driver knew a decision was coming. A reasonable person would have watched both inbox and spam folder.

Berow concerns common law service under different legislation and does not rule on section 15(1A). Its value for party wall practice is as recent High Court guidance on receipt, the concept Knight makes decisive whenever service falls outside the statutory list.

Why Does This Matter for a Party Wall Award and the Fourteen Days to Appeal?

It matters because the appeal period is short and may begin with an email rather than an envelope.

Practical lessons for London owners carrying out or facing works:

  • Treat the email date as day one. If an award arrives by email, assume time is running. The day of service is counted.
  • Check junk folders during a live dispute. After Berow, a filtered or unread email is a weak answer where email has been the normal channel.
  • Say in writing how documents should be served. A statement of willingness and a specified address bring service within section 15(1A). Without one, the sender relies on proof of receipt.
  • Use a listed method when certainty counts. Post or personal delivery under section 15(1) protects the server.

What Evidence Will a Party Wall Surveyor Need to Prove Service?

A surveyor relying on email needs evidence of receipt, not just of sending.

A sound service file would hold:

  • the recipient’s written statement agreeing to electronic service and naming the address;
  • the sent email with its attachment, timestamp and any delivery or read receipt;
  • a reply or other step showing the document was opened;
  • proof of posting where a hard copy followed.

In Knight, time-stamped emails fixed the sequence to the minute. In Berow, delivery receipts and the earlier pattern of email contact were central. If a service point reaches the county court, a surveyor may have to give factual evidence of these matters, so contemporaneous records are worth more than recollection. The same holds for a surveyor instructed as an expert witness: opinions must rest on documents that can be produced.

FAQ

What should be included in a party wall notice?

A party structure notice must give the building owner’s name and address, the nature and particulars of the proposed works, and the date they will begin. Excavation notices must come with plans and sections. The notice must then be validly served on every adjoining owner under section 15.

How much does a party wall surveyor cost in London?

Fees depend on the works, the number of adjoining owners and whether one agreed surveyor or two surveyors act, so no single figure is reliable. Under section 10 the surveyors decide who pays the reasonable costs, commonly the building owner.

How to find a good party wall surveyor?

Look for a surveyor who regularly administers the Act in London, explains the statutory role clearly and keeps disciplined records of notices, service and awards. Professional body membership and experience of similar projects matter more than proximity. Ask how documents will be served.

Can my neighbour attach things to my boundary wall?

Not without a legal right or consent. If the wall stands wholly on one owner’s land, a neighbour who fixes items to it risks a trespass claim. If it is a party wall, the Act permits only the works it lists, following notice.

Conclusion

Email can be good service of party wall documents, either under section 15(1A) with the recipient’s stated agreement or, following Knight v Goulandris, where receipt can be proved. Berow shows the courts taking a practical view of receipt in 2026.

Next steps for owners and surveyors:

  1. Agree service arrangements in writing at the start of the project.
  2. Diarise the appeal deadline from the earliest date an award was received in any form.
  3. Take legal advice promptly if an appeal is being considered, because the time limit is strict.

References

  1. Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 15 (Service of notices etc.). legislation.gov.uk.
  2. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (Electronic Communications) Order 2016, SI 2016/335. legislation.gov.uk.
  3. Knight v Goulandris (2018) EWCA Civ 237, Court of Appeal, 20 February 2018. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  4. Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 10 (Resolution of disputes). legislation.gov.uk.
  5. Berow v Maidstone Borough Council (2026) EWHC 635 (Admin), High Court, 17 March 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.

Speak to a RICS chartered party wall surveyor

Free initial consultation. Notices, awards and schedules of condition across London and nationwide.

Related services: Party Wall Notices service · our Party Wall FAQs · our London locations · 0204 579 8270